Writing an Open Society

[rowyn]

A long time ago, one of my friends suggested to me that the world would be better off if there were only one human gender: if everyone was hermaphroditic, say. "It'd eliminate gender discrimination. What good do gender differences do us?"

I never liked that idea, although it was hard to articulate why. I've certainly never been fond of gender roles.  But gender itself? I like the diversity of it. It's fun.

After writing A Rational Arrangement, where societal and legal pressure to conform to a heterosexual, monogamous ideal was overwhelming and a major source of conflict for the characters, I wanted to write about a much more open society in The Moon Etherium. I made a magic-rich setting where all the characters had easy access to a variety of powers, including shape-shifting. In their society, gender is a choice: a choice one can change on a whim, and doing so is unremarkable. Many characters in The Moon Etherium strongly identify with a particular gender and do not change it. Most identify as male or female. But some identify as neuter, and some identify as a mixture, and some change randomly, and all of this just happens and no one much worries about it. One of the challenges of writing the story was presenting this without giving it undue emphasis, because to the characters it's trivial.

In a similar vein, there's no societal stance on "this is the right kind of sexuality" or "the right kind of relationship". The female protagonist, Ardent, had a wife for many years, and is now attracted to the male protagonist, Miro. She never reflects on her sexual orientation because of this, because her society doesn't care. Straight/gay/pan/etc are all ordinary and acceptable and the society doesn't feel a need to categorize them. The protagonists do have an explicit conversation about relationship types (monogamy, polyamory, etc.), because 'we should agree on what our relationship is, since there is no default.'

The Moon Etherium's romantic subplot is M/F and between two people, so in a sense the LGBTQIA+ and poly-postive aspects of the setting are not integral to the story. The main protagonists strongly identify as male and female, respectively. There were various reasons why I wanted to write their story this way. Part of that was that my protagonists live in a society without gender roles, and I wanted to distinguish between "gender roles" (which is a meaningless concept to them) and "gender identity" (which they do have, although it's more fluid for some than others).  I didn't want to write about a society where characters took on male forms to do masculine activities and female ones to do feminine activities (though that could be interesting!)  But I did want one where the people still felt that male/female/etc. had some meaning. Because gender is fun.

Comments

[terrycloth.livejournal.com]

Everything is better when everyone's a shapeshifter. I'd think this would be obvious.

[rowyn]

Yeah, having a fixed physical form that you can't easily change by conscious choice is kind of weird and inconvenient, really. :D

[sythyry.livejournal.com]

I was with you right up to the last sentence.

[gavinfox.livejournal.com]

Eh, I would say, 'gender tweaking, changing, going from having to not having, and roleplay can often be fun to play with'. Would that still be the case with those who identify as neuter or genderless? Or is even that too much to say?

[rowyn]

Gender is annoying? :D Are you in the "we'd be better off all the same gender" camp or something more complicated?

[gavinfox.livejournal.com]

I think Bard identifies as neuter, and doesn't like associating with gender stuff with regards to zirself... and can't easily find fun in gendering/gendered thought?

[sythyry.livejournal.com]

Gender mostly makes me miserable. I know perfectly well this is a minority opinion.